House of Lords HL Paper 79 · SME perspective · November 2026

A plan is not proof of readiness: what the House of Lords resilience report means for your business

A calm, practical reading of the House of Lords report: no new legal duties for SMEs, and no reason to confuse Government recommendations with requirements on your business.

A small leadership team discussing practical business resilience planning in a bright office

On 16 November 2026, the House of Lords National Resilience Committee published a 102-page report on national resilience. It creates no new legal duties for businesses. But it does set out why, for smaller firms, the more likely pressure points are contracts and insurance rather than statute.

The report, Are we ready? Building a culture of resilience, draws on 169 written submissions and 21 evidence panels. It contains five chapters and 75 numbered recommendations. As of publication of this article, the Government has not responded to it.

It is a House of Lords select committee report, not a white paper, a bill or legislation. Almost all of its recommendations are directed to the Government, and many concern how the state organises itself. None creates a legal obligation for your business.

That makes the useful question for an SME less “What will I be required to do?” and more “What might a customer or insurer ask me to show?”

What the report proposes for SMEs

Recommendation 40 proposes a three-tier framework for business resilience. The first tier covers businesses whose continued operation is essential to national resilience; those businesses would face statutory preparedness and continuity duties. In the second tier, resilience requirements would be set and assured through contracts.

The third tier is the wider business community, expressly including SMEs. The Committee proposes supporting this group through voluntary, practical, sector-specific guidance and incentives such as tax reliefs and cheaper insurance for compliant businesses.

For an SME, the proposed direction is support rather than obligation. The report does not define which businesses would fall into each tier, set a turnover or headcount threshold, or attach a date to the tier-three proposals. It asks the Government to work out those details.

That distinction matters. A proposal in a committee report is not a rule in force, and it is not a timetable for your business.

Where pressure is more likely to come from

The framework is a recommendation. The two routes most likely to affect an SME in practice, customer contracts and insurance, already exist.

The Committee records a witness’s warning that regulating larger businesses may lead those businesses to increase requirements on SMEs in their supply chains. That sits alongside the proposed second tier, where resilience requirements would be set through contracts. In practice, requests are more likely to reach many smaller firms through larger customers than through statute.

A customer could ask about continuity arrangements, how quickly you report a disruption, whether you have tested your plans, or what insurance cover you hold. Some of these points may already appear in your agreements.

A useful first step is to read the contracts that matter most. Check who is responsible for business continuity, what you must report and how quickly, whether customers can ask for evidence of testing, and what cover you have promised. If a clause is unclear, get advice before assuming what it means.

Picture a 40-person manufacturer that supplies one large retail group. Nobody there has been asked for a continuity plan. But the trading agreement already lists the insurance the manufacturer must hold and gives the customer a right to audit. When that agreement comes up for renewal, the questions asked in the meeting will come from the contract, not from Parliament.

Two colleagues reviewing a customer contract together in a bright office

Insurance is part of the resilience conversation

The report records that much of the resilience value of cyber insurance lies not only in a payout but also in the standards insurers require, including incident response arrangements and security controls.

It also records low uptake of cyber cover among smaller firms. Two figures it cites are worth knowing, with the caveat that both are other people’s numbers that the Committee is reporting rather than findings of its own. The first is Government data showing that half of UK SMEs faced a cyber attack in 2025. The second is Howden research cited in the report, which found that 60% of SMEs without cyber cover go bankrupt within six months of a severe incident.

For a business, the practical point is to understand what your policy covers and what the insurer expects you to have in place. Make sure the people responsible for your response know whom to contact, where the policy details are, and what steps to take if an incident affects your systems or data.

Insurers’ questions and customers’ questions can overlap: can you keep serving customers, how would you respond to a disruption, and what evidence can you provide? A short, clear record of your arrangements is more useful than a large plan that nobody can explain.

Why testing matters more than the document

The key point comes at paragraph 66 of the report: having plans and frameworks is not, by itself, evidence of preparedness. The Committee says plans “must not become compliance documents or tick-box exercises”.

The report illustrates the gap with evidence from telecoms operators. They told the Committee their networks were resilient to local and regional incidents, but that business continuity arrangements were often not understood and not tested. The concern was not simply missing paperwork; it was whether people knew what to do and whether the arrangements had been tried.

A small team running a tabletop exercise with sticky notes and printed scenario sheets

So ask your leadership team: what did we last test, when did we do it, what did we learn, and what changed afterwards? Those answers can show whether a plan is usable and help you explain your operational resilience to a customer or insurer.

A practical exercise does not have to interrupt the business or involve a large external programme. Scenario planning can start with a short discussion: for example, imagine a key supplier is unavailable, or your premises cannot be used. Talk through who makes decisions, what customers need to know, and how you would keep essential work moving. Record gaps and assign actions.

Practical steps that suit a smaller business

None of these actions is required by this report. They are proportionate ways to make your arrangements more useful and easier to explain.

  • Keep a simple, dated record. For each exercise or real disruption, note the scenario, who took part, what did not work and what you changed. It need not be a complex evidence system.
  • Review key contracts and insurance. Focus first on the agreements that matter most to your customers and operations. Check continuity clauses, reporting times, requests for testing evidence and promised insurance cover.
  • Test a realistic disruption. Choose something that could stop you trading and talk it through with the people who would respond. A focused tabletop exercise, where people discuss what they would do, is a practical starting point.
  • Give someone ownership. Make clear who keeps the plan current, arranges exercises and follows up agreed actions. Keep the responsibility proportionate to the size of the business; it does not need a new department.
  • Check equipment that relies on an analogue phone line. The report notes the Public Switched Telephone Network switch-off on 31 January 2027. Check with your provider whether any alarms, lifts, card terminals or older systems you rely on need a different connection.

The test is not how many pages sit in a folder. It is whether the right people can find the key information, make decisions and carry out the first practical steps.

Common misunderstandings to avoid

It is easy to read a report about national resilience and assume it creates new requirements for every business. This one does not. Its recommendations are directed mainly to the Government, and the proposed support for SMEs is voluntary.

It is also a mistake to treat a plan as proof that your business is prepared. A plan that has not been discussed, tested or updated may not help when people need to act. Keep the response manageable: focus on the disruptions that would matter most to your business and learn from each exercise.

Finally, do not confuse a customer’s contractual request with a statutory duty. A customer may ask for evidence under an agreement; that is different from a new legal obligation created by this report.

Frequently asked questions

Does the report create new duties for SMEs?

No. It is a House of Lords select committee report, not legislation. Its tier-three proposals for the wider business community, including SMEs, are for voluntary guidance and incentives.

Does the report name a standard we should be working to?

No. It does not recommend or name a specific standard. Its proposal for the wider business community, including SMEs, is voluntary, sector-specific guidance rather than a certification to reach.

What should we do first?

Read the continuity and insurance terms in your most important customer contracts. Then choose one realistic disruption and talk through how your team would respond, noting any gaps and actions.

A practical next step

For a proportionate start, our two-page SME guide to the House of Lords report sets out what it means for a business your size, with every figure referenced back to the report. You can request it from the briefing page on our website. You can also read about our Business Resilience service.

If you would like to discuss a practical next step, contact Philip Alcock at philipalcock@realrisksolutions.com or call +44 (0)1223 230205.

This article is a plain-English summary of a published report, for information only. It is not legal advice and is not a substitute for reading HL Paper 79 or taking advice on your own arrangements. Figures and quotations are taken from the report; where a figure is attributed to a third party, the Committee is reporting it rather than adopting it as its own finding.

Useful next step

Get the two-page SME briefing

The guide summarises what HL Paper 79 means for smaller businesses and includes the source references behind its figures.

Request the briefing